Thoreau’s version of, “Ye Must be Born Again”

The first time literature spoke to me was in college when I was introduced to Henry David Thoreau. Thoreau voted with his feet that “modern” life was not accommodating to his soul, and so he retreated to the woods and sought authenticity, declaring, “I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived.”

The notion of “not having lived” as one comes to the end of his life stunned me and did so because I saw its relevance to my life at age 21. And, I did not fully understand then why, but it immediately brought to my mind the famous words of Jesus, “What will it profit a man if he gains the whole world and loses his own soul?” The “not having lived” of Thoreau and the “loss of soul” that Jesus spoke of were one and the same, but I could not really explain it at that point. The insight was intuitive.

Thoreau recognized that modern life was increasingly alienated, that it increasingly cut man off from nature and from himself, turning him into a cog in an industrial apparatus. Thorough intuitively knew what we have come to witness more overtly, that Western civilization was producing a culture of consumers, people whose modus operandi was “consuming”, or “getting stuff.” (And, if he were alive today, he would marvel at how prescient he had been.!) Jesus too recognized that mankind in his day were overly invested in the “stuff” of the day, though rampant consumerism had not blighted human consciousness yet. But he recognized that mankind was missing the point, that they were guilty of the sin of “misplaced concreteness” even then taking for real that which was only ephemeral. When Jesus taught, “Ye must be born again” he was telling us, “Hey, there is another dimension of life that you need to tap into. What you see is not all that there is. You are not all that you know yourself to be. You are more than that mere concept.”


9 thoughts on “Thoreau’s version of, “Ye Must be Born Again”

  1. Sandeep Bhalla

    A logically apt interpretation. But question is what it means to live? Is chasing every desire or thought is living? Or sitting in some ‘holy’ building, whole life is living? That needs to be understood.


    1. literary lew Post author

      I agree terms need to be defined, and “life” is a fundamental term. I think it is a term the definition of which is elusive and even unobtainable. I don’t think we can ever know what it “means” for the moment when we accomplish that we have become…for want of a better term…”god” or “God.” And then we have really violated the gates of hell! Life is just something that happens and some of us are given to analyze it more than others and for that we are “cursed” with the angst of alienation. Sometimes I saw, facetiously, “O, give me the comfort of ignorance for a few minutes!”

      Thanks to both of you gentlemen for commenting. This is so interesting and the discussion is good for the soul.


  2. N℮üґ☼N☮☂℮ṧ via Victoria

    I find it interesting that many learn through introspection (going to the woods) that one needs to become more outrospective. That, IMO, is representative of tapping into ‘another dimension of life.’ I think authenticity is realized through empathy and by understanding that we are all connected and need each other in order to survive and thrive as a species.

    Based on child development studies, there is evidence suggesting we are intrinsically prosocial. We’ve been living in times where culture has conditioned us into believing in ‘original sin’, that we are depraved, and all that that entails. The musings of the ‘Enlightenment’ era added fuel to the fire. When you have time, I recommend watching a lecture I posted on my blog a while back:

    I produced a short video with an abstract of this lecture.

    The 21 century brings promise. I plan on posting this video (below) in my next blog entry, but I’m still working on the into. I thought the video complimented your post, so I’ll post it here.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s